Here, then, are the group's estimation of the best films that premiered during 2013 but failed to secure New York distribution (and hence eligibility for the Skandies proper, which has a two-year window) by the end of 2015. As it happens, fewer and fewer notable films—where "notable" is defined as "made some noise on the fest circuit and were likely to be seen by several voters"—are failing to secure a week-long NYC run. Three years ago we finally hit what I consider a tipping point: Five people who usually vote in this section (out of a pool of only 17) chose to abstain, saying they just hadn't seen enough eligible titles. As a result, a number of films would have cracked the top 20 on the basis of a single vote. So I whittled the list down to just a top 10, and there's been no need to re-expand it since. Indeed, this year one film succeeding in cracking the top 10 with just a single big vote (mine), and the number of voters has now dwindled to the point where I'm seriously considering dispensing with the Undies altogether. It's a good thing, really—in a perfect world, there'd be no need for this category.
As ever, disclaimers abound. While roughly 40 professional and amateur cinéastes vote in the main survey, a smaller subset takes part in what's become known as the Undies—basically the folks who make it out to multiple festivals. (You can find their names way at the bottom.) And of course circumstances dictate that the results will skew in favor of those undistributed films that have been most widely seen, with a particular advantage going to anything that played at Toronto. No doubt many other excellent films were simply not seen by enough people to make the cut; feel free to mention overlooked favorites in the comments.
Alas, I'm too harried at the moment to write up commentary on 10 films, many of which I haven't seen. So I've let various folks who've posted their thoughts on the IMDb or Letterboxd provide a characteristic remark.
NOTE: Several people voted for Jodie Mack's "Dusty Stacks of Mom: The Poster Project"—so many, in fact, allotting so many points, that it would have eked out a narrow victory. When I looked it up to find a poster and a blurb, however, I discovered that it's only 41 minutes long, which makes it a short film according to the Undies/Skandies rules, and hence ineligible. Because I discovered this so late (last night), and because it's incumbent upon the voters to make sure the films they vote for are features (I note the 45-minute rule every year), I'm not gonna go to the trouble of having all of them resubmit ballots. I've simply disqualified "Dusty Stacks" and bumped the next ten films up one rank. But apparently it's worth seeing.
In reverse chrono:
#10 Blind Detective (Johnnie To) 23 pts | 2 votes
"At 130 minutes, Wai Ka-Fai's script takes on more subplots than necessary. The mystery plot had me most engaged, and I liked how the crime-solving plot sprouted in multiple cases. The final reveal seemed rushed and a bit far-fetched to be truly believable. And there were details that should have been caught. The subplot with Andy Lau trying to woo a dance instructor played by Gao Yuan Yuan is cute but extraneous. It's like the filmmakers brainstormed every possible thing for Andy Lau and Sammi Cheng's characters to do, filmed all of them, and couldn't decide what to take out."
#9 Love Is the Perfect Crime (Arnaud & Jean-Marrie Larrieu) 24 pts | 3 votes
#8 Phil Spector (David Mamet) 28 pts | 1 vote
#6 (tie) Nobody's Daughter Haewon (Hong Sang-soo) 32 pts | 3 votes
#6 (tie) Mouton (Gilles Deroo & Marianne Pistone) 32 pts | 3 votes
#5 Three Interpretation Exercises (Cristi Puiu) 36 pts | 4 votes
#4 Sorrow and Joy (Nils Malmros) 39 pts | 3 votes
#3 Our Sunhi (Hong Sang-soo) 42 pts | 4 votes
#2 Love Battles (Jacques Doillon) 47 pts | 4 votes
#1 Club Sandwich (Fernando Eimbcke) 61 pts | 4 votes
THE VOTERS: Mike D'Angelo, Alex Fung, Sky Hirschkron, Don Marks, Theo Panayides, Vadim Rizov, Dan Sallitt, Michael Sicinski, and Blake Williams. (Yes, we're down to only nine, which is why no film received more than four votes.) Thanks to all.
For the record, here are the next 10 films, in alphabetical order. Half of them got only one vote.
Age of Panic (Justine Triet)
Daredevils (Stephanie Barber)
An Episode in the Life of an Iron Picker (Danis Tanovic)
i hate myself :) (Joanna Arnow)
The Major (Yuriy Bykov)
The Oxbow Cure (Yonah Lewis & Calvin Thomas)
See You Tomorrow, Everyone (Yoshihiro Nakamura)
Sentimental Education (Júlio Bressane)
Shield of Straw (Takashi Miike)
Tamako in Moratorium (Nobuhiro Yamashita)
2000: Battle Royale (Kinji Fukasaku)*
2001: Pulse (Kiyoshi Kurosawa)*
2002: Turning Gate (Hong Sang-soo)
2003: Not on the Lips (Alain Resnais)
2004: The 10th District Court—Moments of Trial (Raymond Depardon)
2005: Tale of Cinema (Hong Sang-soo)
2006: Taxidermia (György Pálfi)*
2007: Secret Sunshine (Lee Chang-dong)*
2008: Just Anybody (Jacques Doillon)
2009: Face (Tsai Ming-liang)
2010: Hahaha (Hong Sang-soo)
2011: Dreileben: Beats Being Dead (Christian Petzold)
2012: Eat Sleep Die (Gabriela Pichler)
* (released commercially after the window of eligibility had closed)